Unfortunately, my liner came with holes and slits in multiple areas of it. It was still functional after some patching, but it was not something that should have to be worried about during set up and could affect sanitation if by chance the holes weren’t properly patched.

When we opened our liner it had two holes in it. Thankfully once we put the liner in the tub the holes were well on the outside of the tub at least. (Full disclosure we never contacted the company for a replacement because I'm due in a few days and it probably wouldn't get here in time.)

Edit: After seeing my review the company contacted me and graciously issued a full refund due to the liner having had holes.

Do wish these were a bit tighter fit and that the seams were nicer, the plastic is loud and crinkly and a bit unsightly, but it does the job.

We use these liners in our aqua doula pool at Atlanta Birth Center. They work great and give us a disposable option that makes cleanup super easy. I did receive one box of liners that leaked, which is why I didn't give 5 stars. That said, the liners are usually a very reliable product.